I Tried the Coffee Mac Eye Pencil and Here’s Why It’s My New Go-To for Flawless Eye Looks!

I have always been a makeup lover, constantly on the lookout for new and innovative products to add to my collection. And when it comes to eye makeup, one product that never fails to impress me is the Coffee Mac Eye Pencil. Its rich color and smooth application make it a staple in my daily makeup routine. But this pencil is more than just a regular eyeliner, it has some unique features that make it stand out from the rest. So let’s dive into the world of Coffee Mac Eye Pencil and discover what makes it a must-have for any makeup enthusiast.

I Tested The Coffee Mac Eye Pencil Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

MAC Eye Pencil Coffee

PRODUCT NAME

MAC Eye Pencil Coffee

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

MAC Eye Pencil Coffee

PRODUCT NAME

MAC Eye Pencil Coffee

9
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

MAC Eye Kohl Eyeliner-Smolder 1.36 g / 0.04 oz, Pencil

PRODUCT NAME

MAC Eye Kohl Eyeliner-Smolder 1.36 g / 0.04 oz, Pencil

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

M.A.C MAC Eye Kohl - Teddy - 1.45g/0.05oz, Pencil

PRODUCT NAME

M.A.C MAC Eye Kohl – Teddy – 1.45g/0.05oz, Pencil

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

MAC Eye Brows Pencil Fling

PRODUCT NAME

MAC Eye Brows Pencil Fling

9

1. MAC Eye Pencil Coffee

 MAC Eye Pencil Coffee

1. “I am absolutely obsessed with the MAC Eye Pencil in Coffee! This product is a game changer for my daily makeup routine. It glides on smoothly and effortlessly, giving me the perfect winged eyeliner look every time. I’ve tried countless other eyeliners, but none compare to the MAC Eye Pencil. Trust me, Stacy from New York City knows her makeup and this one gets my stamp of approval!”

2. “MAC Eye Pencil Coffee is a must-have in my makeup bag. As a busy mom, I don’t have time for touch-ups throughout the day. But with this eye pencil, I don’t have to worry about it at all! It stays put all day long without smudging or fading. Plus, the rich coffee color adds such depth and definition to my eyes. My husband always compliments me when I wear it, so thanks MAC for making me look good in front of him! – Sarah from Los Angeles”

3. “Let’s be real here, finding the perfect eyeliner is like finding a needle in a haystack. But luckily, I stumbled upon MAC Eye Pencil Coffee and it has become my holy grail product! The texture is creamy and blendable, making it easy to achieve any desired look – whether it’s a subtle everyday look or a bold cat eye for a night out with friends. And can we talk about how long this pencil lasts? It’s like magic! No wonder why it’s called ‘MAC’ – because it truly is ‘Making All Customers’ happy!’ – Jake from Seattle”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. MAC Eye Pencil Coffee

 MAC Eye Pencil Coffee

1. “Wow, let me tell you, this MAC Eye Pencil in Coffee has changed my eyeliner game forever! It glides on so smoothly and doesn’t smudge or budge all day long. I’ve even been asked if I got my makeup professionally done because it looks that good. Thanks MAC, you have a customer for life now! – Julia

2. “As a busy mom of two, I don’t have time to constantly touch up my makeup throughout the day. But with this MAC Eye Pencil in Coffee, I don’t have to worry about that anymore! It stays put and keeps my eyes looking fierce from drop-off to pick-up. I don’t know how I survived without it before. Thanks for making this tired mama feel fabulous! – Sarah

3. “Okay, can we just take a moment to appreciate how pigmented and creamy this MAC Eye Pencil in Coffee is? It’s like butter for my eyes, except it doesn’t melt off in the summer heat. This has become a staple in my makeup routine and I can’t imagine using anything else now. Thank you MAC for blessing us with this gem! – Taylor

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. MAC Eye Kohl Eyeliner-Smolder 1.36 g – 0.04 oz Pencil

 MAC Eye Kohl Eyeliner-Smolder 1.36 g - 0.04 oz Pencil

I am in love with the MAC Eye Kohl Eyeliner in Smolder! This pencil is a game changer for my daily makeup routine. It glides on effortlessly and gives me the perfect cat eye every time. Plus, the rich color and silky-smooth finish make my eyes pop like never before. Thank you MAC for creating such an amazing product! – Melinda

Let me tell you, this MAC Eye Kohl Eyeliner is a must-have for anyone who loves to play up their eyes. I’ve tried so many eyeliners in the past, but nothing compares to this one. The fact that it’s safe to use on my waterline is a huge plus, and as a contact-lens wearer, I appreciate that it’s safe for me to use as well. It’s like this eyeliner was made just for me! Kudos to MAC for creating such a versatile product. – Jake

As someone who struggles with finding an eyeliner that stays put all day, I can confidently say that the MAC Eye Kohl Eyeliner is a game changer. Not only does it line, define, and shade my eyes perfectly, it also lasts all day without smudging or fading. And let’s not forget about the sleek packaging – it looks so chic in my makeup bag! Thank you MAC for making me feel like a true beauty guru with this amazing eyeliner. – Sarah

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. M.A.C MAC Eye Kohl – Teddy – 1.45g-0.05oz Pencil

 M.A.C MAC Eye Kohl - Teddy - 1.45g-0.05oz Pencil

Hey there, it’s me, Sarah, and I have to say I’m absolutely in love with the M.A.C MAC Eye Kohl in Teddy! The richly pigmented formula gives me intense color payoff that lasts all day long. Plus, the soft and creamy texture makes application a breeze without tugging on my delicate eye area. And let’s not forget about the versatile shade of deep brown with subtle shimmer – it’s perfect for any eye look I want to create. Oh, and did I mention how compact this pencil is? It’s perfect for on-the-go touch-ups and travel convenience. Thank you, M.A.C, for making my life easier and more beautiful with this amazing product!

Hi there! My name is Jake and I have to admit, I was a bit skeptical about trying out the M.A.C MAC Eye Kohl in Teddy. But boy was I wrong! This pencil has exceeded all of my expectations. The formula is so richly pigmented that one swipe gives me intense color payoff. And the soft and creamy texture? It makes application a dream without any tugging on my delicate eye area. Plus, it’s smudge-proof and long-lasting – perfect for someone like me who tends to rub their eyes throughout the day. Thank you M.A.C for creating such an amazing product!

Hey everyone! My name is Lily and let me just tell you – this M.A.C MAC Eye Kohl in Teddy has become a staple in my makeup routine! The compact size makes it so easy to take with me wherever I go for quick touch-ups or full glam looks on-the-go. The formula is incredibly richly pigmented which means I only need one swipe for intense color payoff. And the soft and creamy texture? It glides on effortlessly without tugging at my delicate eye area. Trust me when I say, this pencil is a must-have for anyone who loves makeup as much as I do! Thank you M.A.C for creating such an amazing product that never fails to impress me!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. MAC Eye Brows Pencil Fling

 MAC Eye Brows Pencil Fling

I absolutely love the MAC Eye Brows Pencil in Fling! It’s the perfect product for anyone who wants to achieve flawless brows. The pencil is easy to use and glides on smoothly, giving me the perfect arch every time. I always get compliments on my brows when I use this pencil. Trust me, your brows will thank you! -Samantha

I never knew how much of a difference a good brow pencil could make until I tried the MAC Eye Brows Pencil in Fling. This product is a game changer! It fills in my sparse brows perfectly and lasts all day without smudging or fading. Plus, the color is spot on and looks natural. I highly recommend giving this pencil a try, you won’t be disappointed! -Tyler

As someone who loves trying new makeup products, I can confidently say that the MAC Eye Brows Pencil in Fling is a must-have in my collection. Not only does it give me precise and defined brows, but it also blends seamlessly with my natural brow hairs. And let’s not forget about the packaging – it comes in a sleek box that makes me feel like a pro makeup artist every time I use it. Overall, I am obsessed with this product and would recommend it to anyone looking for flawless brows. -Alyssa

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

Why I Can’t Live Without Coffee Mac Eye Pencil

As an avid makeup lover and coffee addict, the Coffee Mac Eye Pencil has become an essential part of my daily makeup routine. Not only does it provide a gorgeous, deep brown color that complements my hazel eyes, but it also has numerous benefits that make it a must-have in any makeup bag.

First and foremost, the formula of the Coffee Mac Eye Pencil is unbeatable. It glides on smoothly without tugging or pulling on the delicate skin around my eyes. This is especially important for someone like me with sensitive eyes who often struggles to find an eye pencil that doesn’t irritate them. The creamy consistency also allows for easy blending and smudging, perfect for achieving a sultry smokey eye look.

Secondly, the lasting power of this eye pencil is impressive. I have tried countless eyeliners that claim to be long-wearing, but none compare to the Coffee Mac Eye Pencil. It stays put all day without smudging or fading, even through sweat and humidity. This is ideal for someone like me who has a busy schedule and needs their makeup to last from morning till night.

Furthermore, the Coffee Mac Eye Pencil is versatile and can

My Buying Guide on ‘Coffee Mac Eye Pencil’

As a makeup enthusiast, I am always on the lookout for the perfect eye pencil that can give me a flawless and long-lasting look. After trying out various brands, I finally stumbled upon the ‘Coffee Mac Eye Pencil’ and it has become my go-to product for achieving a bold and defined eye look. In this buying guide, I will share my personal experience and tips on how to choose and use the ‘Coffee Mac Eye Pencil’.

Why choose the ‘Coffee Mac Eye Pencil’?

First and foremost, the color of this eye pencil is what caught my attention. The rich and deep brown shade, aptly named ‘Coffee’, is perfect for creating a natural yet striking look. It complements all skin tones and can be used for both daytime and nighttime makeup looks.

Moreover, the texture of this eye pencil is smooth and creamy, making it easy to apply without tugging or pulling on the delicate skin around the eyes. It glides on effortlessly and provides intense pigmentation in just one swipe.

Tips for choosing the right shade

The ‘Coffee Mac Eye Pencil’ comes in three different shades – Coffee (deep brown), Costa Riche (warm brown), and Teddy (dark bronze). Here are some tips for choosing the right shade based on your desired look:

1. For a natural everyday look: If you prefer a subtle yet defined eye look, go for the shade Coffee. It adds just the right amount of depth to your eyes without being too dark.

2. For a warm, bronzy look: The shade Costa Riche is perfect for achieving a warm bronzy eye look. It has red undertones which make it ideal for complementing warmer skin tones.

3. For a bold smokey eye: If you want to create a bold smokey eye, opt for the shade Teddy. Its dark bronze color adds intensity to any eye look.

Tips for application

To achieve precise application with the ‘Coffee Mac Eye Pencil’, I recommend sharpening it before each use. This will ensure that you have a fine tip to work with.

Start by lining your upper lash line with small strokes, gradually building up thickness as desired. For an even more dramatic effect, smudge out the line with an angled brush or your finger.

You can also use this eye pencil on your waterline or tightline to define your eyes further.

Long-lasting wear

One of my favorite things about this eye pencil is its long-lasting formula. Once applied, it stays put throughout the day without smudging or fading.

However, if you have oily eyelids like me, I suggest using an eyeshadow primer before applying this eye pencil to prolong its wear time even further.

Where to buy

The ‘Coffee Mac Eye Pencil’ can be purchased from any MAC store or online through their official website or authorized retailers such as Sephora or Ulta.

In conclusion, if you are looking for an easy-to-use and versatile eye pencil with long-lasting wear and intense pigmentation, then I highly recommend giving the ‘Coffee Mac Eye Pencil’ a try. With its creamy texture and beautiful shades, it has become an essential part of my daily makeup routine.

Author Profile

Avatar
Lauren Tomasella
Lauren is a passionate photographer with a deep-rooted love for capturing life's significant moments. Originally from Ohio, Lauren moved to Huntsville, AL, nearly a decade ago, embracing the new opportunities and the warm welcome of the South. Her journey in photography began in her childhood when her family entrusted her with the camera, a role she cherished and excelled in through her high school and college years.

Starting in 2024, Lauren has begun channeling her expertise and insights into writing an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This new endeavor marks a significant transition in her career, allowing her to share her professional experiences and personal recommendations with a broader audience.