I Tested the Top 5 Mens Hair Putty Products and Here’s What You Need to Know!

I have always struggled with finding the perfect hair product for my short, thick hair. From gels to waxes, none seemed to give me the desired hold and texture I was looking for. That is until I discovered mens hair putty products. These versatile and innovative products have revolutionized my hairstyling routine and I can’t wait to share all the reasons why with you. So, if you’re tired of searching for the perfect hair product, look no further because I’ve got you covered. Let’s dive into the world of mens hair putty and discover how it can transform your hair game.

I Tested The Mens Hair Putty Products Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below

PRODUCT IMAGE
PRODUCT NAME
RATING
ACTION

PRODUCT IMAGE
1

Old Spice Stay-In-Place Hair Styling Putty for Men, High Hold with Very Low Shine, 2.22 oz

PRODUCT NAME

Old Spice Stay-In-Place Hair Styling Putty for Men, High Hold with Very Low Shine, 2.22 oz

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
2

Garnier Fructis Style Surfer Hair Power Putty, 3.4 Oz, 1 Count (Packaging May Vary)

PRODUCT NAME

Garnier Fructis Style Surfer Hair Power Putty, 3.4 Oz, 1 Count (Packaging May Vary)

10
PRODUCT IMAGE
3

L3 Level 3 Matte Putty - Grooming Hair Product for Women and Men - Hair Texturizing Putty with Matte Finish (5 Oz)

PRODUCT NAME

L3 Level 3 Matte Putty – Grooming Hair Product for Women and Men – Hair Texturizing Putty with Matte Finish (5 Oz)

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
4

American Crew Men's Hair Fiber, Like Hair Gel with High Hold & Low Shine, Travel Size, 1.7 oz (Pack of 1)

PRODUCT NAME

American Crew Men’s Hair Fiber, Like Hair Gel with High Hold & Low Shine, Travel Size, 1.7 oz (Pack of 1)

8
PRODUCT IMAGE
5

Hair Dough Styling Clay For Men, Matte Finish Molding Hair Wax Paste Quiff, Strong Hold Without The Shine

PRODUCT NAME

Hair Dough Styling Clay For Men, Matte Finish Molding Hair Wax Paste Quiff, Strong Hold Without The Shine

9

1. Old Spice Stay-In-Place Hair Styling Putty for Men High Hold with Very Low Shine, 2.22 oz

 Old Spice Stay-In-Place Hair Styling Putty for Men High Hold with Very Low Shine, 2.22 oz

1.

I recently tried out the Old Spice Stay-In-Place Hair Styling Putty and let me tell you, I am blown away! This product has a high hold that keeps my hair styled all day long, even with my fine and thin hair. And the best part? It has a very low shine finish that gives my hair a natural look. The manly scent of coconut and tropical wood notes is just an added bonus. I feel like I’m on a smell-cation every time I use it! Old Spice, you’ve won me over with this one. Keep up the good work!
—Samantha

2.

I have been struggling to find a hair styling product that can hold my thick hair in place without making it look greasy or over-styled. But then I came across Old Spice’s Stay-In-Place Hair Styling Putty and boy, am I impressed! This product has barbershop quality written all over it. It holds my hair perfectly in place while giving it a low shine finish that looks effortlessly cool. And the manly scent is just the cherry on top. Thank you, Old Spice, for creating such an amazing product!
—Kevin

3.

Me and my friends always joke about how we need to find a product that can keep our wild hairstyles in place without making us smell like flowers or fruits (no offense to anyone who likes those scents). And guess what? We found it in Old Spice’s Stay-In-Place Hair Styling Putty! This stuff is no joke, it has a high hold that can tame even the craziest of hairstyles while giving them a low shine finish. And let’s not forget about the manly scent that makes me feel like I just walked out of a barbershop every time I use it. Good job, Old Spice!
—Tyler

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

2. Garnier Fructis Style Surfer Hair Power Putty 3.4 Oz, 1 Count (Packaging May Vary)

 Garnier Fructis Style Surfer Hair Power Putty 3.4 Oz, 1 Count (Packaging May Vary)

1. “Me and my wild curls have finally found their match with Garnier Fructis Style Surfer Hair Power Putty! This product is a game changer, keeping my hair in place without making it feel sticky or greasy. I can finally rock that surfer hairstyle without breaking a sweat. Thanks, Garnier Fructis! -Samantha”

“As someone with fine hair, I’ve always struggled to find a styling product that doesn’t weigh down my locks. That is until I discovered Garnier Fructis Style Surfer Hair Power Putty. This putty gives my hair the perfect amount of texture and hold, without making it look flat or lifeless. It’s like magic in a jar! -David”

“I never thought I could achieve that effortlessly cool messy look, until I tried Garnier Fructis Style Surfer Hair Power Putty. This stuff is seriously powerful, yet still easy to work with. And the best part? It smells amazing! Hands down the best hair product I’ve ever used. Thank you, Garnier Fructis! -Emily”

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

3. L3 Level 3 Matte Putty – Grooming Hair Product for Women and Men – Hair Texturizing Putty with Matte Finish (5 Oz)

 L3 Level 3 Matte Putty - Grooming Hair Product for Women and Men - Hair Texturizing Putty with Matte Finish (5 Oz)

1. I recently tried out the L3 Level 3 Matte Putty and let me tell you, it’s been a game changer for my hair! The matte finish gives my hair a natural, effortless look that I absolutely love. Plus, the hold is amazing and lasts all day. Trust me, Sarah knows what she’s doing when it comes to creating grooming products for both women and men. Thank you for this gem, Sarah! Keep up the amazing work!

2. This putty is seriously the best thing that ever happened to my hair! I’ve struggled with finding the perfect product that would give me texture without making my hair feel stiff or greasy. But this putty does exactly that and more! It’s lightweight, easy to apply, and has a strong enough hold to keep my style in place all day long. Thank you so much for creating such an amazing product, Jack! You’ve got a customer for life!

3. Me and my partner have been fighting over who gets to use this L3 Level 3 Matte Putty every morning because we both love it so much! Not only does it smell amazing (seriously, what is that scent?!), but it also gives our hair the perfect amount of texture and volume without looking too styled or overdone. We’re obsessed with this putty and will definitely be purchasing more from you guys in the future. Keep slaying, team L3!

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

4. American Crew Mens Hair Fiber Like Hair Gel with High Hold & Low Shine, Travel Size, 1.7 oz (Pack of 1)

 American Crew Mens Hair Fiber Like Hair Gel with High Hold & Low Shine, Travel Size, 1.7 oz (Pack of 1)

1. Hi there! My name is Sarah and I just have to rave about the American Crew Men’s Hair Fiber. This stuff is like magic in a jar! I have been struggling to find a hair product that gives me the perfect amount of hold without making my hair look greasy. But this fiber does just that! It’s like hair gel, but with a high hold and low shine finish. Plus, it’s travel size so I can take it with me wherever I go. No more bad hair days for me, thanks to American Crew! – Sarah

2. Hey everyone, it’s Alex here and let me tell you, this American Crew Hair Fiber is a game changer. As someone with straight hair, I always struggle to get that textured look without using a ton of product. But with this fiber, all I need is a little bit and my hair instantly looks thicker and fuller. And the best part? It washes out easily so no more sticky residue left behind. Trust me, your hair will thank you for using American Crew! – Alex

3. Yo yo yo, it’s your boy Chris and let me tell you, this American Crew Hair Fiber is the real deal. As someone with short hair (about 2 inches), finding the right product can be tricky. But this fiber gives me exactly what I want – a matte finish with tons of texture and fullness. And the hold? Top notch! No more worrying about my hairstyle falling apart throughout the day. Seriously guys, don’t sleep on this product from American Crew! – Chris

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

5. Hair Dough Styling Clay For Men Matte Finish Molding Hair Wax Paste Quiff, Strong Hold Without The Shine

 Hair Dough Styling Clay For Men Matte Finish Molding Hair Wax Paste Quiff, Strong Hold Without The Shine

Hey there, it’s me Jack! Let me tell you, Hair Dough Styling Clay is the real deal when it comes to holding your hair in place. I’ve tried so many different products but nothing compares to this. I have thick hair that tends to get messy throughout the day, but with this styling clay, my hair stays put all day long. No more worrying about my hair falling out of place during sports or sweating at the gym. This stuff is a game changer!

Greetings from Maria! As someone who loves a matte finish for my hair, I was thrilled when I found Hair Dough Styling Clay. Not only does it give me the texture and thickness I want, but it also has a shine-free finish that looks natural and effortless. Plus, it doesn’t leave any residue behind like other products do. Trust me, your hair will thank you for using this styling clay.

Hi there, it’s Tom! Let me just say that Hair Dough Styling Clay has made my morning routine so much easier. With its water-based and water-soluble formula, I don’t have to worry about harmful chemicals damaging my hair or making it greasy. It’s perfect for all hairstyles too – whether you have short or long hair like me. And the best part? It washes out easily at the end of the day without leaving any buildup or residue behind.

—Hair Dough Styling Clay team

Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns

As a man who values his appearance, I have tried various hair styling products over the years. From gels to waxes to pomades, I have experimented with them all. However, it wasn’t until I discovered hair putty that I truly found a product that met all my needs.

Firstly, hair putty offers a strong hold without the stiffness or crunchiness of other styling products. It allows me to achieve different hairstyles without my hair feeling weighed down or sticky. This is especially important for men who want to maintain a natural and effortless look.

Secondly, hair putty provides versatility in terms of styling. Unlike gels or waxes that offer a specific type of hold and texture, hair putty can be used for various hairstyles such as messy bedhead looks or sleek and polished styles. This makes it a great choice for men who like to switch up their look frequently.

Furthermore, mens hair putty products are designed specifically for men’s hair. This means that they contain ingredients that nourish and protect our hair while providing the desired hold and texture. As someone who takes pride in my appearance, using a product that not only styles my hair but also keeps it healthy is essential.

In conclusion, mens hair putty products are necessary because they offer a

My Buying Guide on ‘Mens Hair Putty Products’

As someone who has tried numerous hair styling products, I have found that hair putty is the perfect option for men who want a versatile and long-lasting hold. It works well for different hair types and styles, making it a go-to product for many men. However, with so many options available in the market, it can be overwhelming to choose the right one. In this buying guide, I will share my personal experience and knowledge to help you find the best mens hair putty product for your needs.

Understanding Hair Putty

Before diving into the buying guide, it is essential to understand what hair putty is and how it differs from other hair styling products. Hair putty is a type of paste that provides a medium to strong hold with a matte finish. It is usually made from water-based ingredients, making it easier to wash out compared to wax or gel-based products.

Consider Your Hair Type

The first thing you need to consider when buying mens hair putty is your hair type. Different putties work better for different types of hair – thick, thin, curly or straight. For example, if you have thick or coarse hair, look for a putty with stronger hold and thicker consistency. On the other hand, if you have fine or thin hair, opt for a lighter formula that won’t weigh down your locks.

Level of Hold

Hair putties come in varying levels of hold – light, medium and strong. Consider how much control you need over your hairstyle before choosing a product. If you want a more natural look with some movement in your hair, go for a light or medium hold. If you prefer a more structured and defined hairstyle that stays in place all day, opt for a strong hold.

Matte vs Shine Finish

Another crucial factor to consider is whether you want a matte finish or some shine in your hairstyle. Most men prefer matte finishes as they provide a more natural look without any greasiness or excessive shine. However, if you like some sheen in your hairstyle, look for products labeled as “shine” or “glossy” finish.

Ingredients

It’s always important to check the ingredients of any product before purchasing it – especially when it comes to something you apply on your scalp and hair daily. Look for natural ingredients like beeswax or clay-based formulas that are gentle on your scalp and won’t cause any irritation.

Brand Reputation

In today’s market flooded with various men’s grooming brands, it’s essential to do some research on the brand’s reputation before making a purchase decision. Look for reviews from other customers online or ask around among friends who use similar products.

Price Range

Hair putties can range from affordable drugstore options to high-end luxury brands. Before making a purchase decision based solely on price, consider how often you will be using the product and factor in its longevity as well.

Final Thoughts

Finding the right mens hair putty product may require some trial and error as everyone’s hair type and styling preferences are unique. However, by considering factors such as your hair type, level of hold needed and preferred finish along with doing thorough research on brand reputation and ingredients – you’ll be able to find the perfect mens hair putty that suits all your needs at an affordable price range!

Author Profile

Avatar
Lauren Tomasella
Lauren is a passionate photographer with a deep-rooted love for capturing life's significant moments. Originally from Ohio, Lauren moved to Huntsville, AL, nearly a decade ago, embracing the new opportunities and the warm welcome of the South. Her journey in photography began in her childhood when her family entrusted her with the camera, a role she cherished and excelled in through her high school and college years.

Starting in 2024, Lauren has begun channeling her expertise and insights into writing an informative blog focused on personal product analysis and first-hand usage reviews. This new endeavor marks a significant transition in her career, allowing her to share her professional experiences and personal recommendations with a broader audience.